Sinclair, Kimberly
Shannon, D. M.
(2012). Perceptions of school
library programs and school librarians: Perspectives of supportive school
administrators. Teacher Librarian, 39,
17-22. Retrieved from http://www.teacherlibrarian.com
Article Summary:
Previously,
studies examining the school principals’ perceptions of the impact and role of
school librarians and library programs sampled principals within a particular
state or region; Shannon, however, became interested in the opinions of
principals who had already been identified by school librarians as supporting
the library/librarian’s role in staff and student engagement and performance. Since
increased collaboration between school librarians and other school staff
constitutes a vital step in transforming traditional school libraries into school-wide,
collaborative learning commons, it makes sense that increased support from
principals should begin with identifying common traits of supportive dynamics already
in place. The main goals of the study included: identifying the source of
principals’ awareness surrounding school libraries, determining what principals
should be taught about the library’s role—and how to better support their
school’s library/librarian—while undergoing administrative credential preparation,
and, lastly, to identify available avenues for school librarians to cultivate greater
administrative support.
Aside
from having a personal affinity for libraries, the study revealed that principals
develop their perceptions about the school library a number of ways: through
feedback from other staff about the librarian’s role and educational impact; by
keeping abreast of educational research on the subject of school libraries, acquired
through professional journals and conferences; from serving on school
technology committees and, not surprisingly, by gaining a deeper understanding
and appreciation for information literacy in general, as accomplished by direct
collaboration with the school librarian. Although principals receive some
training on administering school libraries during the course of the credential
preparation courses, Shannon identified two areas of this training as having
the greatest potential for increasing principals’ awareness of/support for
school libraries: preparation on how to facilitate collaboration between the
school librarian and other instructional staff, and how to identify/hire highly
qualified school librarians. By having an awareness of these two aspects, principals
learn that they can best support school libraries by, inversely, hiring library
staff keen on and adept at collaborative teaching, promoting a collaborative
work environment in general, emphasizing the value of the librarian’s role to
instructional staff in particular, and publicly recognizing gains achieved
through successful collaboration.
While
the majority of the article focuses on what administrators can do to better
support school libraries, Shannon concludes by summarizing what the study has
to say about what librarians can do on their end to court their principals’ endorsement.
For one, Shannon advises school librarians to consistently meet and dialogue
with administrators about shared vision statement, goals, and objectives for
the library/learning commons; this promotes mutual buy-in by assuring that
everyone is on the same page, and reassures administrators that the librarian
is taking concrete, observable, measurable steps towards achieving these shared
goals. Additionally, school librarians can legitimize their requests by
presenting the administration with a detailed budget request for the school
year—and it certainly doesn’t hurt to provide long-term budget requests and
timelines dedicated to the school’s strategic plan. Finally, Shannon points out
that principals are more likely to support the school library staff and its
programs when the school librarian undertakes ongoing assessments aimed to
evaluate the effectiveness of policies and programs over time.
Evaluation:
While this
article yields many insights into producing a crop of emerging administrators
whom are dedicated to proactively advocating for school library programs, it
has less to offer in the way of advice for school librarians seeking to curry
support among incumbent, less “library enlightened” administrative/staff, which
I would hope to see more of. Yes, Shannon does identify several very practical
tactics, such as proposing budget requests and meeting regularly with
administrators to discuss goals and objectives, but what about when librarians
are dealing with administrators entrenched in outdated perspectives—or who
simply feel their hands are tied and have abandoned attempts to reinvigorate/revamp
the school library in lieu of budget cuts—who are unwilling to meet with school
librarians to discuss what they view as a moot point? When the best
recommendation is to start from the top (administratively, that is) and gain
support from the top, down, what can be done when the “top” is wholly
unresponsive?