Showing posts with label process. Show all posts
Showing posts with label process. Show all posts

Sunday, September 16, 2012

The argument against Educational Technology

Crompton, Marc

Richtel, M. (2011, September 04). Grading the digital school: In classroom of future, stagnant scores. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/04/technology/technology-in-schools-faces-questions-on-value.html?_r=4


I just read an article published last September in the New York Times discussing an initiative in an Arizona school district to invest heavily in technology in the classrooms.  The district is faced with going back to the taxpayers to continue to support an increased tax rate to invest further in technology while standardized test scores have remained the same since the initiative began, even when scores in surrounding areas have risen.

While much of the article makes this connection between increased use of educational technology and little documentable effect on learning, Richtel, the article’s author, is careful to not take a clear stand on either side of the argument.  In my mind there are two important issues coming out of this article.

Probably the most obvious issue, at least to educators, relates to equating the benefits to the use of technology to what is tested in standardized tests.  Technology is about the process.  It can help make understanding deeper.  Standardized tests are about content.  Cramming for a test using rote memorization can, potentially, help a test score.  But as anyone knows who has taken this approach, the information memorized is often lost within a couple of days of the exam.  If students learn less content but understand, and thus remember, that material more deeply, the net effect is a better educated graduate, regardless of what the standardized test scores say.

Richter makes a point about the quality of teacher using the technology: “Good teachers, he said, can make good use of computers, while bad teachers won’t, and they and their students could wind up becoming distracted by the technology.”  I don’t think that this argument is quite so simple.  Different teachers have different skills, personalities and teaching styles.  The effective use of technology does not define a good teacher.  However, technology in the hands of a teacher who does not use it effectively has no benefit.  As is pointed out later in the article, technology can become a distraction and can make the learning environment less effective.  Technology, as with any educational tool, has to be used for the right reasons and in effective ways.  Technology, by itself, does nothing for education.

Educational technology is an important tool in this day and age.  We live in a world filled with technology and students need to develop the skills to use these tools effectively in a work environment.  They need to be comfortable with technology and need to learn how to learn so that they can keep on top of change.  They also need to know how to pick up a pencil and sketch or grab a shovel and dig.  High Tech devices are not the answer to every situation in the educational world or in the world at large.  We need to focus on what our goals are in education, measure our progress with appropriate instruments and use the best methods available to reach those goals.

Sunday, September 9, 2012

Powering Down for School

Crompton, Marc

Prensky, M. (2008). Turning On the Lights. Educational Leadership, 65(6), 40-45.Retrieved from ERIC via EBSCOHost.

Prensky presents a straightforward argument where school used to be a place where students were enlightened with new knowledge of the world outside of their immediate experience and students today actually "power down" for their in-school time.  The school used to be the fountain of knowledge and the teacher was the one who introduced new ideas to students and explained how the world worked.  As the students are exposed to an ever increasing amount of information through TV and digital sources, the teacher is less needed to introduce those new ideas.  Unfortunately, the education system has remained stuck in the content delivery mode, giving students information that they already have or have no interest in.  The role of the education system needs to become more one of helping students build context and meaning around the information that they already have.

This article was published 4 years ago and while the basic idea that education needs to be process not content focused is no longer new to anyone who is paying attention, the idea of students actually "powering down" as Prensky calls it is a concept that is new to me.  I love the way he uses the light bulb analogy to bring a sense of urgency to the issue while explaining a component that is not necessarily evident to all.  The concept that the majority of students are shutting off for the school day simply because of a lack of relevance is scary.  His claim is that 50-70% of middle and high school students are bored.  It means that not only are schools not doing their job, they are actually harming students.  This is unforgivable. 

K-12 schools, especially those like the university-prep school that I teach in, hide behind the need for quantifiable measures to get our students into the competitive universities that they are applying to.  If student X needs to get into Ivy League University Y, they need to have a GPA of Z and have received a 5 on at least 4 AP exams.  Then we say that if they want to succeed at said university, they'd better be experienced at writing intense standardized tests.  My feeling is that this attitude is less and less true.  The universities aren't stupid.  They're dealing with the same issues that we are.  Students need to know how to build knowledge not regurgitate facts.  Their assessment and evaluation methods will have to shift just as ours do.  I'm sure in many instances, they are way ahead of us.  So let's encourage inquiring and help students to build their own knowledge.  Worry less about content and let's get the students powered back up!